Skip the guesswork on baby gear

Subscribe for honest reviews, must-have recs, and smart tips from a first-time mom who’s done the research so you don’t have to.

    ​

    Papablic vs Momcozy vs Eufy: Which Bottle Washer Is Best? (2026)

    Papablic vs Momcozy vs Eufy: Which Bottle Washer Is Best? (2026)

    Papablic SafeguardPlus, Momcozy DeepClean D8 and Eufy S1 Pro bottle washers lined up side by side

    This post is in partnership with Papablic. All opinions are my own and I only endorse products I’ve personally tested.

    If you’re shopping for the best bottle washer, you’re probably deciding between the same three I was: the Papablic SafeguardPlus, the Momcozy DeepClean D8 and the Eufy S1 Pro. I ran all three side by side for 8 weeks and compared them on cleaning, speed, drying, capacity, water, counter space and cost.

    I’m currently 3 months postpartum with my second baby, and back at work full time. At the end of a very long workday, dinner, and making it through bedtime routines, the last thing I want to do is wash what feels like a million bottles and pump pieces.

    I’ve hit my convenience era this time around, and I’ve been on a mission to find the products/services that are etching out more time for the things I want to be doing, not have to be doing.

    So, enter bottle washers. I definitely did not have a bottle washer with my first, and it’s one of those moments where I look back and question my sanity. The amount of hours a bottle washer is saving me, not to mention an achy back, is, in my opinion, worth the cost right there.

    The quick verdict

    • Best overall: Papablic SafeguardPlus. The fastest wash of the three, and the only one that filters your water. The only washer where there was no standing water after a normal wash. No water marks or residue left behind.
    • Best for capacity: Eufy S1 Pro. The roomiest inside, if you have the counter space. The top rack felt best for small pump pieces.
    • Best for small kitchens: Momcozy DeepClean D8. The smallest footprint (not by much) and the lowest price. Plus it has wheels that make moving it around quite easy.
    Papablic SafeguardPlus, Momcozy DeepClean D8 and Eufy S1 Pro bottle washers lined up side by side

    Before we get into the detailed comparison between these 3 bottle washers, lets just briefly chat about what bottle washers even are, what they can do, and what the internet wants moms to believe. (Hi scare tactics, I’m calling your bluff).

    Bottle washer 101

    Most bottle washers on the market are essentially 4-in-1. Washer, dryer, sterilizer and storage, all in one cycle. That’s different from a bottle sterilizer, which only sanitizes bottles that are already clean, so you still have to scrub everything first.

    Beyond saving time, here’s why parents (including myself) go for one:

    • Sanitizing is built in. The CDC recommends sanitizing feeding items daily for babies under 2 months, preemies and babies with weakened immune systems. A washer’s high-heat step means no boiling pots.
    • Everything dries fully. The CDC says to let bottles air-dry instead of towel drying, and notes drying racks can trap moisture.
    • Clean, closed storage. Parts stay dry and dust-free until you need them.
    • Bottles stay out of the sink, which the CDC also recommends.
    Front of the Papablic SafeguardPlus with its separate filtered water tank beside it
    Front of the Eufy S1 Pro bottle washer
    Front of the Momcozy DeepClean D8 bottle washer

    Disclosure: This post is sponsored by Papablic. All opinions are my own. This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

    Do you even need a bottle washer?

    No, and I’m living proof. The CDC says washing bottles by hand in a clean basin or running them through the dishwasher works. I did it for a year and a half with Ezra.

    My hot take is this, a bottle washer is a convenience buy. What you get is so much time back and one machine that washes, sterilizes, dries and stores everything, so you’re not having to constantly manage a drying rack of tiny valves, flanges, bottles, nipples, etc.

    It absolutely earns its spot if you’re pumping, have more than one kid using bottles or prep bottles for daycare. If you’re washing one or two bottles a day, you could keep your money. Your sink has you covered.

    Flat lay of breast pump parts, flanges and baby bottles waiting to be washed
    Pile of pump parts, milk collectors and bottles from one day of pumping

    How I tested

    I ran the same loads through each machine: Ronini and Pigeon bottles, Eufy and Momcozy pump + pump parts including milk left sitting for a few hours for the initial test. Then I used each bottle washer for 1 week at a time after going back to work, so it was washing all my items every single night so I could really get to know each bottle washer and how it cleaned and dried the bottles intimately. I used our Spokane tap water in all three and checked it with the TDS meter.

    A day of dirty baby bottles and breast pump parts on the kitchen counter
    Loading bottles and pump parts into the Papablic SafeguardPlus rack

    Cleaning

    This one feels a little subjective here. All 3 bottle washers do a good job at cleaning, and I think no matter what one you choose, the job will be done well. My thoughts are quite knit picky because there wasn’t any huge glaring difference when the bottles came out. I immediately opened each bottle washer after their normal cycle to check how dry and clean the bottles were without allowing them to sit for a few more hours to fully dry if there was water left. And 2 out of the three did not pass the test.

    Papablic SafeguardPlus

    The bottles were completely spotless. There was no water residue or droplet spots inside or outside the bottle. The pump parts always came out completely dry, and thoroughly clean. This machine felt like after the end of a normal cycle, all the parts that were washed (plastic, silicone or glass) were the cleanest.

    Water jets spraying bottles and nipples inside the Papablic SafeguardPlus during a wash cycle
    Unloading clean, dry pump parts from the Papablic SafeguardPlus

    Eufy S1 Pro

    The bottles were completely dry, but the flanges in the pumps had a bit of water left, so they weren’t 100% dry. The really small crevices from my Spectra duckbill flange had some water residue dried inside.

    Pump flanges and valves loaded on the Eufy S1 Pro top rack
    Breast pump flanges sitting in the Eufy S1 Pro top rack

    Momcozy DeepClean D8

    Similar to the Eufy, there were some watermarks left behind on some of the smaller pieces, and a few parts had some water that wasn’t completely dried too.

    Duckbill valve placed in the Momcozy DeepClean D8 rack
    Milk collector loaded over a spray jet in the Momcozy DeepClean D8

    Winner: Papablic. Every single piece, part and bottle came out completely spotless. No leftover water or watermarks.

    Speed and cycles

    Having a bottle washer that can do this job in less time that it takes me to clean my kitchen feels pretty cool. For me, it wasn’t completely necessary though because I don’t wash my bottles multiple times a day, and I’m never in that big of a hurry. My routine is washing all my bottles and pump parts at the end of the night and having them ready to go in the morning. So this section didn’t matter that much to me, but I’m sure there are some parents out there where the speed from dirty to clean matters a lot.

    Papablic SafeguardPlus

    • Fastest cycle: Rapid+, a 12 minute wash. It’s wash only, so parts come out wet.
    • Normal wash (wash, sterilize and dry): 1 hour and 14 minutes total.
    • Other cycles: Clean runs 29 minutes, Heavy runs 45 minutes and drying adds 45 to 60 minutes.

    Momcozy DeepClean D8

    • Fastest cycle: 19 minutes. It’s wash only, so parts come out wet.
    • Normal wash (wash, sterilize and dry): 1 hour and 38 minutes total.
    • Cycle breakdown: Clean runs 29 minutes, steam sterilization adds 8 minutes and drying adds 60 minutes.

    Eufy S1 Pro

    • Fastest cycle: 19 minutes, and it also doesn’t dry.
    • Normal wash (wash, sterilize and dry): 1 hour and 36 minutes total.
    Comparing cycle times on the bottle washer displays
    Eufy S1 Pro bottle washer display showing the cycle time
    Momcozy DeepClean D8 display showing the cycle time

    Winner: Papablic. For all cycles, whether normal or rapid, it wins on speed. Rapid+ is 7 minutes faster than the other two, and a normal wash finishes over 20 minutes sooner.

    Drying

    All of these bottle washers dried the bottles 100%, but where the difference really started showing up were in the small pump pieces where water could collect or become trapped.

    Papablic SafeguardPlus

    Has two fans that help dry all the parts. The Papablic was the only bottle washer that consistently dried every single piece, including the small pump pieces and the inside of the duckbill flange for my Spectra. There were never any droplets of water that came off any of the items, which I cannot say for the other two.

    Momcozy DeepClean D8

    Has one fan. This bottle washer consistently left the most “standing” water. I would find water even on the brim of some of the bottles, and definitely in the small crevices of the flanges. Plus, it left the white residue inside that too, which is exactly the path the milk takes.

    Eufy S1 Pro

    This bottle washer also has two fans. The eufy was a bit hit or miss, and sometimes all pieces were completely dry, other times there would be some water droplets left over. From what I can tell, it really was dependent on how I loaded in the pump parts and pieces. If you became consistent and loaded it the same exact way every time, you’d likely figure out how to guarantee dry parts.

    Winner: Papablic. No matter how I loaded in the pump parts and pieces, they were consistently 100% dry and spotless, even in the hard to dry places with lots of small areas and divots where water could easily become trapped.

    Capacity

    Papablic SafeguardPlus

    Can hold 8 bottles or 2 full sets of pump parts. For me, I typically have 2-3 bottles a day and then 1 full set of pump parts and they all fit with room to spare, plus it cleans all parts effectively. Bottles + the big parts of my pumps go on the bottom rack, and the small pump parts on top with nipples and other smaller bottle pieces.

    This is the only one of the three that can also have nipples or pump valves (from bigger pumps like the spectra) fit in there alongside 8 bottles. It’s quite tight, but it is possible.

    Momcozy DeepClean D8

    8 bottles. It’s much more square and compact, very straightforward. Has big openings at the bottom, so you wouldn’t really be able to put many other pieces in there… and definitely not smaller pieces like you would with the other two. You can remove the bottle arms, but the jets aren’t removable so the bottom really is mostly for bottles (and the larger pump pieces), but you need to ensure they’re placed properly here.

    The bottles are very compact in here, without any wiggle room to add additional items on the bottom like the Papablic.

    One thing worth noting is it has the sprayer accessory piece. That’s the one thing this has that none of the other two do not have. This means it can go inside a product like a milk collector and spray the inside effectively.

    Eufy S1 Pro

    Eufy says that it’s rated for up to 10 bottles, but only has true racks for 8. I couldn’t figure out where the other two bottles would go, I even tried adding 2 of my 5 oz bottles to the top rack but the lid wouldn’t quite close. The bottle holders also aren’t really made for 5oz bottles, they aren’t big enough to rest on the arms, but 8 oz+ bottles would fit fine. This doesn’t impact how clean the bottles get, just an annoying oversight imo.

    Like the Momcozy, each bottle gets an individual jet that sprays into the bottle. You can remove the bottle arms if you want to put other pieces in there like the bulkier pump parts or milk collectors. Theoretically you could put a milk collector on a jet.

    As mentioned in other places, it is the largest of all 3, and if you don’t want to use the bottle sprayer jets, you can remove them + remove the arms that hold the bottles for more of a flat, bulk wash whatever situation. I appreciate that. Plus the rack capacity is quite a bit larger, so if you have lots of small pieces too from your pump, nipples, whatever, you’re going to be able to wash a bit more there. (It’s not a significant amount, but you’ll likely fit a few additional pieces in there.)

    Winner: Eufy. It’s the roomiest of the three, it’s more flexible with different configurations, and the racks have quite a bit of different levels and sizing for a variety of different pieces.

    Top Racks

    I’ve yet to see anyone break down the top racks side by side before, so here’s all the info that others are probably leaving out. I didn’t think that the top rack would matter that much, until I started using these washers, and quickly realized how important the design of it is…

    Momcozy DeepClean D8

    I’m gonna be honest. I hate this rack. I probably wouldn’t hate it as much as I do, if I didn’t try the other two machines. The gaps are quite large for a product designed to clean small pieces… For example, my Eufy S1 Pro Portable Pump Flanges and valves I have to place very carefully otherwise there’s a chance if sprayed incorrectly, they could fall through the holes. Not the end of the world, just annoying.

    The way Momcozy designed this bottle washer feels more turnkey and specific to each piece and part, where the other two are more like goosebumps, and you can choose your own adventure.

    The one thing I DO like about the top rack of this, is that it has stations to put the nipples on top of. And perhaps some of the larger pump valves.

    Holding the Momcozy DeepClean D8 top rack to show the gaps
    Nipples placed on the Momcozy DeepClean D8 top rack nipple stations

    Papablic SafeguardPlus

    I don’t have strong opinions about this top rack, it’s sort of a plain vanilla feature. There’s nothing that I absolutely hate about, but also nothing that I love about it. It does the job effectively, and i can fit quite a lot of pieces and parts on it. It has some different levels and angles that are helpful and can fit everything I need to fit on there.

    Holding the Papablic SafeguardPlus top rack
    Papablic SafeguardPlus top rack from an angle showing its levels
    Papablic SafeguardPlus top rack loaded with nipples, rings and pump parts

    Eufy S1 Pro

    My favorite rack, i think it’s really spacious and i don’t have to worry about any of my small pieces falling through. I like the angles of the basket, and it feels like everything is goign to get perfectly cleaned. On the rack, it has this one little section with tiny little spikeys that are perfect for the small little drip pieces from your pump part. Keeps them stable. Also Eufy is the only one that my Boon Trove milk collectors fit on the top rack

    The one thing i don’t like about Eufy is the bottle holder doesn’t feel like it can be moved at all. If you have 5oz bottles, they won’t hit the top of the holder, where the 8 oz bottles are fine. But I really don’t use the larger bottles. This doesn’t impact how clean the bottles get, just an annoying oversight. I wish you could drop the holders down a notch. They can be removed.

    Holding the Eufy S1 Pro top rack
    Eufy S1 Pro top rack loaded with bottle parts and small pump pieces
    Milk collector fitting in the Eufy S1 Pro top rack

    Winner: Eufy. I actually love the top rack, it sort of itches a part of my brain that likes organization and putting things in different compartments. I don’t know if that makes sense, but I just like it. The gaps are small, no pieces will fall through and there are lots of different sections for specific pieces of your pumps or bottles.

    Water Purity

    This is the category nobody talks about. Every cycle runs a few liters of tap water over your baby’s bottles, and whatever is in your water goes on them too. There’s a level of how much everyone cares about what’s in their water. If you’re a reverse osmosis type of family, stop reading now, and Papablic is the one for you. But if you’re a Brita kind of family like me, water purity matters, but you’re not losing sleep over it.

    As I was researching these bottle washers, I discovered Eufy has a hard water softener, but no filter. Momcozy has neither softener or filter and only Papablic had a water filter.

    I was curious what my water purity levels looked like so, I tested my water with a TDS meter I got off Amazon. Layman’s terms: A TDS meter measures dissolved minerals. It can’t detect lead or PFAS, so I can’t verify those claims from my kitchen. What I can see is a lot less going onto our bottles, no white film, and no jugs of distilled water. For context, a USGS study estimated that at least 45% of US tap water contains at least one type of PFAS.

    This isn’t a reason to panic about your tap water. It’s a reason to choose the washer that filters it.

    Out of the Papablic’s filtered tank: 0 ppm
    Our Spokane tap water: 77 ppm

    TDS meter reading 0 ppm in the Papablic SafeguardPlus filtered water tank
    The Papablic SafeguardPlus separate water tank with built-in filter

    Papablic SafeguardPlus

    A built-in filter in the water tank. Papablic says it reduces lead, PFAS, chlorine and hardness. The filter sits inside the tank and you can watch it filter as you add your tap water directly inside.

    Momcozy DeepClean D8

    No water treatment. Momcozy recommends distilled water.

    Eufy S1 Pro

    A softener cartridge in the bottom of the Eufy tank that reduces hard water minerals. This helps with the white residue left behind, but it doesn’t filter.

    Winner: Papablic. It’s the only one of the three that filters.

    Counter space and setup

    These are big and bulky, period. No matter what one you go with, they’re going to take up space on the counter. Here’s my argument when it comes to how big they really are, and why it’s not that much different than manually drying them.

    I have a “grass drying rack” (yes, that one that every single mom has), and in terms of footprint (actual counter space it takes up), it was the same size or bigger than all the bottle washers. Yes, the washers are bulkier, and you can hide away the mat, but for me it’s actual less visual clutter having all my bottles and pump parts INSIDE a closed area than all sitting on a drying mat. 1 visually feels less than 20 for me.. Might just be a me thing?

    Momcozy DeepClean D8, Papablic SafeguardPlus and Eufy S1 Pro bottle washers lined up side by side

    Papablic SafeguardPlus

    The biggest difference here is that the water tank isn’t a part of the machine, it’s actually it’s own piece. This allows for counter space flexibility because you can have the tank in the sink, behind the bottle washer, on the side, wherever makes the most sense based on how your kitchen is set up. Because of that, the bottle washer becomes the smallest in size in comparison to the other two.

    Momcozy DeepClean D8

    The smallest footprint of the three. It’s quite compact and I can appreciate how much can be put in such a small area.

    Eufy S1 Pro

    The biggest, tallest and widest of the three. That’s the biggest takeaway: it feels quite bulky and sprawls across the counter. It will take up a lot of room, so if you don’t have a big kitchen this one might feel quite big.

    All three drain through a hose, so wherever it lives in your kitchen, it needs to be near a sink. The drain hoses are maybe ~2 feet long, so you don’t have to be directly next to the sink, but it has to be close.

    Winner: Tie. Momcozy for small spaces. Papablic for its small size and flexible setup, since the water tank is detached and can go wherever works in your kitchen.

    Upkeep, cost and internet sentiment

    Papablic SafeguardPlus

    Price: $399.99
    Replacement filters: $69.99 per 90 washes. About $0.70 per wash. Each filter needs to be replaced after 30 cycles.

    4.2 stars on Amazon from 223 ratings, and 72% of those are 5 stars. The happiest reviewers are exclusive pumpers, twin parents and moms of multiple kids, who say it took the nightly bottle routine off their plate and cleans really well. The complaints are mostly about reliability. A handful of buyers had a unit stop working after a few months and said Papablic’s support was hard to reach (email only), though they did respond.

    Momcozy DeepClean D8

    Price: $359.99 list.

    No filter to replace, but the distilled water adds up. I compared the cost of distilled water which is about $1.39 per 128oz, and calculated the cost of that per 90 cycles based on how much water each cycle uses, and it came out to $94.19 per 90 washes.

    4.1 stars on Amazon from 139 ratings, with 68% at 5 stars. People who upgraded from smaller washers love that a full day of bottles and pump parts fits in one cycle. The most common complaints match mine: once 8 bottles are in there isn’t much room left for nipples and other small parts, small pump pieces can fall through the top rack, and a few people noticed residue or a cloudy film.

    Eufy S1 Pro

    Price: $429.99 list.

    Softener cartridges: $49.99 per cartridge to be replaced every 40-60 days.

    Customer sentiment is bizarre, because on Amazon it shows there were reviews, but when I try to go find and read any, it says there are none? I’m not sure if they’re trying to hide something, but worth noting. Outside of that I looked through reddit and their website for reviews, and the sentiment is: mostly positive, just thin. Early reviewers say everything comes out spotless and the machine feels premium and well built. The most repeated downside is size, since it takes up a lot of counter space. There just isn’t much long-term owner feedback yet.

    Winner: Papablic. It has the most reviews of the three and the highest share of 5 star ratings, though it’s close with the Momcozy. The Eufy may get there, but there isn’t enough real owner feedback to call it yet.

    The winner for Best Bottle Washer of 2026: Papablic SafeguardPlus

    Papablic SafeguardPlus bottle washer on a kitchen counter with its detached water tank
    Papablic SafeguardPlus and Eufy S1 Pro running side by side on a kitchen counter

    Cleaning was similar for all three of the bottle washers. What separated them were the three things only Papablic did: a 12 minute wash, filtered water and a water tank that isn’t attached to the main unit. That’s why the Papablic is the one I’ve started using daily after going through all the testing.

    The Eufy deserves credit for capacity, and the Momcozy is a solid pick if your kitchen is small and you’re on a strict budget. But for a pumping mom with a toddler, the Papablic does the most.

    The me with my first kid would have told you a bottle washer was a nice to have. Me now with two kids and a much busier and hectic life would tell you it’s one of the baby items I’d buy again first. It’s right up there with my Boon Trove milk collector on my list of nursing products I’d use again.

    [Shop the Papablic SafeguardPlus]

    Which bottle washer is best for you?

    • Get the Papablic SafeguardPlus if you’re pumping or feeding more than one kid, want the fastest wash, care about what’s in your water and need flexibility and different configurations for counter space.
    • Get the Eufy S1 Pro if you want the most room inside and have lots and lots of small little pump pieces
    • Get the Momcozy DeepClean D8 if your kitchen is small, your tap water is good, and you want the lowest price.

    FAQ

    Which bottle washer is the fastest? The Papablic SafeguardPlus. Its Rapid+ cycle is a 12 minute wash. The Momcozy D8 and Eufy S1 Pro start at 19 minutes.

    Does the Papablic Rapid+ cycle dry? No. Rapid+ is a wash only. Use Normal or Heavy when you want everything washed and dried.

    Which bottle washer filters water? Of these three, only the Papablic SafeguardPlus. The Eufy S1 Pro softens water, and the Momcozy D8 doesn’t treat it.

    Do I need to sterilize bottles every time? The CDC recommends sanitizing feeding items at least once a day for babies under 2 months, babies born prematurely, and babies with weakened immune systems. For older, healthy babies, it may not be necessary every time if everything is cleaned carefully. Ask your pediatrician what’s right for your baby.

    Can bottle washers clean pump parts? Yes. The Papablic fits 2 full sets of pump parts per load.

    Is a bottle washer worth it? If you’re pumping or washing a lot of bottles every day, it can save you real time. If you’re washing one or two bottles a day, the sink or dishwasher is fine.

    This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. This post is sponsored by Papablic. All opinions are my own, and I only recommend products I’ve personally tested.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Welcome! i'm lindsay!

    Welcome! i'm lindsay!

    I created Hard Launch Mom to share the real, unfiltered side of modern motherhood.

    Here you’ll find honest product reviews, practical parenting tips, and stories that hopefully are relatable to your experience as a parent. 

    Let the record show that I write all my blogs, from personal experience. I do not use AI to write anything, other than fact check, and look for grammar / spelling errors. I buy all the products and test them before I write one word about them. This is becoming increasingly important and evident in the AI space, and I am coming to you as an authentic, REAL mom with big opinions.

    This space is for parents who want trustworthy recommendations, relatable insights, and a touch of humor along the way. Welcome—let’s figure this out together.

    — Lindsay, Founder of Hard Launch Mom

    I created Hard Launch Mom to share the real, unfiltered side of modern motherhood.

    Here you’ll find honest product reviews, practical parenting tips, and stories that hopefully are relatable to your experience as a parent. 

    Let the record show that I write all my blogs, from personal experience. I do not use AI to write anything, other than fact check, and look for grammar / spelling errors. I buy all the products and test them before I write one word about them. This is becoming increasingly important and evident in the AI space, and I am coming to you as an authentic, REAL mom with big opinions.

    This space is for parents who want trustworthy recommendations, relatable insights, and a touch of humor along the way. Welcome—let’s figure this out together.

    — Lindsay, Founder of Hard Launch Mom

    morE about me

    morE about me

    Join The HLM Fam
    For all the latest

    Subscribe to MY newsletter

    Subscribe to
    my newsletter

    Honest reviews, must-have recs, and smart tips from a mom who’s done the research so you don’t have to.